Barth, Calvin, and Reformed Exegesis – an Excerpt from Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics

The following is an excerpt from Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics, by Craig Bartholomew.


The truth is that Church Dogmatics and Barth’s other works are an exegetical resource that has been sadly neglected by biblical scholars. But what of the claim that Barth is an enemy of theological orthodoxy? Might this not support keeping him at arm’s length? There is certainly room for theological critique of Barth, but what must be understood is Barth’s theologically conservative reaction to the liberalism of his day, and his recovery of the Bible as Scripture, involving at its core a reappropriation of the Reformed tradition and of Calvin in particular.

Barth’s recovery of the Reformed tradition was so damaging to liberalism because he had been one of them. However, as a young pastor he found that liberalism was bankrupt in the aftermath of World War I when it came to addressing his congregation in the European context.

….In his lectures on Calvin, Barth recognizes the unique contribution of Calvin as an expositor of Scripture to the Reformation: “Scripture did not play quite the same part in Reformed Protestantism as in Lutheranism. Its dignity here was one of principle as it never was in Lutheranism, no matter how highly the latter regarded it.”

Cover ArtThe big issue for Reformed Protestantism was “how to give God, the true God, the glory, how to do it here and now,” and against the backdrop of medieval Catholicism, its answer was to look to the Bible as the final norm in faith and life….

Barth identifies three characteristics of Calvin’s exegesis that he finds exemplary. First, there is the extraordinary objectivity of his exegesis. At times Calvin does engage in eisegesis—”if we read nothing into the Bible, we will also read nothing out of it”!—but his exegesis is always characterized by a concern to stay close to the text and to do justice to what is actually there.

The example Barth gives of Calvin’s eisegesis is that Calvin assumes the unity of the message of the Bible when he reads it: though Scripture is polyphonic, the diverse voices are all seeking to say the same thing.

Second, there is the uniformity of Calvin’s exegesis. By this, Barth refers to Calvin’s concern to attend to individual books in their literary totality and to the whole of Scripture: “If in principle it is seen to be right to listen to the Bible, then we should listen to the whole Bible.”

In his commentary work, for example, he is always concerned to expound the whole of a book and not just the parts that have been influential. Calvin’s premise of the verbal inspiration of the Bible did not prevent him from critically examining the trustworthiness of the Bible, but it did give “him a consistent zeal to track down the content of the whole Bible, a zeal incidentally that would also stand historical investigation of the Bible in good stead.”

The third characteristic of Calvin’s exegesis is its relevance. By relevance, Barth is not thinking of application to the cultural and historical context, but the sense that this is God’s Word addressing us. Calvin is at pains to attend to the particularity of texts, but at the same time he is busy with a living dialogue across the centuries. Barth gives the example that when Calvin expounds Paul, “We believe Calvin the more readily because he is not deliberately trying to make us believe but simply setting out what he finds in Paul, yet not, of course, without being able or even trying to hide the fact that he himself believes it. This quiet kinship between the apostle and the exegete speaks for itself.”

©2015 by Craig G. Bartholomew. Published by Baker Academic. Unauthorized use of this material without express written permission is strictly prohibited.


For more information on Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics, click here.

New Release: Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics

Cover ArtRenowned scholar Craig Bartholomew, coauthor of the bestselling textbook The Drama of Scripture, writes in his main area of expertise–hermeneutics–to help seminarians pursue a lifetime of biblical interpretation.

Integrating the latest research in theology, philosophy, and biblical studies, this substantive hermeneutics textbook is robustly theological in its approach, takes philosophical hermeneutics seriously, keeps the focus throughout on the actual process of interpreting Scripture, and argues that biblical interpretation should be centered in the context and service of the church–an approach that helps us hear God’s address today.


“Sophisticated work on truth, listening to Scripture, biblical theology, tradition, historical-critical methods, canon, philosophy, history, literature, theology, and academic inquiry….Above all it stresses the need to listen to Scripture and to God. I warmly commend this book.” – Anthony C. Thiselton, University of Nottingham

“Craig Bartholomew has been laboring in the fields of biblical interpretation and hermeneutics for years, and this book represents the abundant harvest, gathering fruit from many academic fields.” – Kevin J. Vanhoozer, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School

“Any individual interested in biblical hermeneutics should have this volume on a readily accessible shelf. Any classes on the subject should have it as an indispensable vade mecum….Highly recommended.” – James D. G. Dunn, Durham University

“An academically seasoned hermeneutic to be performed in the presence of God and centered in the church–what he refers to as ‘faith-full’ biblical interpretation. Bartholomew’s gift to his reader is the opportunity to think deeply about Scripture in the company of a seasoned scholar.” – Jeannine Brown, Bethel Seminary San Diego

“A smorgasbord of evangelical learning in the service of hearing God’s word in our day. A lifetime of wide reading and reflection has gone into this project.” – Christopher Seitz, Wycliffe College, University of Toronto

“With consummate skill Bartholomew weaves together theology, philosophy, history, and exegesis…. This book will undoubtedly be a landmark in hermeneutics for many years to come.” – Mary Healy, Sacred Heart Major Seminary

Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics is a triumph. Craig Bartholomew provides a clear and gripping account of what it means to hear Scripture as God’s Word.” – C. Stephen Evans, Baylor University

“A milestone for biblical interpretation….The volume is vintage Bartholomew: extraordinarily learned, exceptionally readable, and constructive in its proposal. Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics is the standard to which I shall return again and again.” – Heath A. Thomas, Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary


Craig G. Bartholomew (PhD, University of Bristol) is the H. Evan Runner Professor of Philosophy at Redeemer University College in Ancaster, Ontario. He founded the internationally recognized Scripture and Hermeneutics Seminar and is the author of several books, including Ecclesiastes in the Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms series. He is also an associate editor of the Dictionary for Theological Interpretation of the Bible and the coauthor, with Michael W. Goheen, of The Drama of Scripture, Living at the Crossroads, and Christian Philosophy.

For more information on Introducing Biblical Hermeneutics, click here.

Why Pastor-Theologians Should Read Fiction

The Gospel Coalition shared 4 Reasons Pastor-Theologians Should Read Fiction, from Kevin Vanhoozer and Owen Strachen’s  The Pastor as Public Theologian. "C. S. Lewis put it best when he spoke of the 'enlargement of our being,' observing: 'In reading … [Continue reading]

The Word of the Cross – an Excerpt from Crucified and Resurrected

The following is an excerpt from Crucified and Resurrected, by Ingolf Dalferth. ——– "The sole distinguishing feature that radically separates Christianity and its Lord from other religions and their gods is the cross." Ernst Käsemann’s assertion … [Continue reading]

New Release: Crucified and Resurrected

This major work, now available in English, is considered by many to be one of the finest and most significant contributions to modern Christology. Preeminent scholar and theologian Ingolf Dalferth argues for a radical reorientation of Christology … [Continue reading]

BA Books & Authors on the Web – November 6, 2015

Norman Wirzba, author of From Nature to Creation, was interviewed at Jesus Creed. "How we name things determines how we are going to relate to them. I don’t treat a "weed" the same way as I treat a "flower" even though both are plants. If the world … [Continue reading]

Was Paul Abandoned by His Friends? – an Excerpt from Acts, Volume 4

The following is an excerpt from Acts, Volume 4, by Craig Keener, commenting on Paul's trial in Acts 24:1–26:32. ——– Where are members of the Jerusalem church? According to ancient friendship ideals, friends (which could include recipients of … [Continue reading]

New Release: Acts, Volume 4

This commentary on Acts, Craig Keener’s magnum opus, may be the largest and most thoroughly documented Acts commentary ever written. Useful not only for the study of Acts but also early Christianity, this work sets Acts in its first-century … [Continue reading]

And the winners are…?

Congrats to Dustin T, Brian R, and Spencer C, who each won a copy of The Gospel according to Heretics, by David Wilhite. You will each be contacted to arrange shipment. … [Continue reading]

BA Books & Authors on the Web – October 30, 2015

At Syndicate Theology you can read reflections on Jesus against the Scribal Elite from Dagmar Winter, Tobias Hägerland, Christopher Skinner, and Jason Lamoreaux, along with responses from Chris Keith. "Chris Keith’s book, Jesus against the Scribal … [Continue reading]